Olympics of Reality Singing Shows 2015: #12 Fancy - Joey Cook / American Idol 14

12. FANCY

Joey Cook

American Idol 14

Fancy got that unique distinction of topping the list from one jury member and, at the same time, ranking the lowest from another. Main culprit? Arrangement. While some found it a tad self-indulgent, most panelists thought the arrangement to be totally brilliant. She leaned pretty heavily on her creativity and musicality, took a huge leap, was in no way playing the safe card, and hit a home run. The vocals were incredibly strong and the performance was exactly what she needed to do to stand out.